Copycat Arby's Horsey Sauce Recipe {Video} - Tammilee Tips (2024)

Arby's Horsey Sauce is a horseradish mayo combination perfect for roast beef sandwiches. This easy-to-make, four-ingredient copycat sauce recipe only takes minutes to prepare at home.

Arby's Horsey Sauce Recipe

My husband loves Arby's Roast Beef sandwiches. They are one of his favorite fast-food lunches to grab on the go. Being home this past year, he started missing many of his favorite restaurant meals.

I have been working on making as many copycat restaurant recipes as I can at home. You no longer have to try and stash away extra small packets of Horsey Sauce when you visit Arby's.

You can easily make this sauce at home and not have a fridge full of condiments you can't remember when you grabbed them and have no idea how old they are.

There is nothing quite like the mix of unknown condiments from restaurants stuffed in the butter drawer of a refrigerator.

We love Arby's and hope you love these other great easy recipes we have shared - Jamocha Shake and Arby's Sauce!

Ingredients

Here is a quick overview of the simple ingredients needed to make an epic Arby’s Horsey Sauce! The printable recipe card at the bottom of the post includes specific measurements and step-by-step instructions.

• Cream Style Horseradish
• Mayonnaise
• Sugar
• Salt

Horseradish - There are quite a few options for horseradish at the grocery store these days. I normally find it in the condiment section near the mustard. I highly suggest going with creamy horseradish to save yourself the step of having to blend the horseradish to get the chunks out of it. You can also find it on Amazon.

Equipment Needed

One of the best parts of this recipe is you don't need any special equipment! All you need is a small bowl and a spoon.

We mix our Horsey Sauce in a large bowl and then transfer it to a smaller container for chilling in the refrigerator. I like using a big bowl to mix everything so I have space to get all the ingredients combined.

How to Make Copycat Arby's Horsey Sauce

I've included complete instructions in the printable recipe card at the bottom of the post, but here's a quick version.

1. Combine all ingredients in a bowl, Stir until well mixed together.
2. Cover and chill in the refrigerator for at least 2 hours.

Preparation and Storage

Make Ahead:

Plan time for the Horsey Sauce to sit in the refrigerator for at least an hour. The longer this sauce sits in the fridge, the better the flavors meld together, and it tastes fantastic.

Storage: Always keep leftovers refrigerated in an airtight container, and enjoy them within four days.

Freezing/How to Freeze: The mayonnaise in this sauce makes it a poor candidate for freezing. It will separate and develop an off texture once defrosted.

How to Reheat: Always serve this horseradish mayo sauce cold, as this is when anything with mayonnaise is at its recommended temperature.

Recipe Variations

Substitutions:

There are quite a few options for horseradish at the grocery store these days. I usually find it in the condiment section near the mustard. I suggest going with creamy horseradish to save yourself the step of having to blend the horseradish to get the chunks out of it. You can also find it on Amazon.

Vegetarian Option: This recipe is naturally vegetarian.

Vegan Option: Vegans should swap the mayonnaise and creamy horseradish with vegan substitutes to make this copycat Arby’s Horsey Sauce vegan.

Gluten-Free: The ingredients in this sauce recipe are generally gluten-free, but look for a gluten-free label on the mayonnaise and horseradish if you are highly sensitive and want to avoid cross-contamination.

Smaller Serving Size + Larger Group/More Servings: This recipe makes one cup of Horsey Sauce. Scale it up or down to your desired yield.

Make It Spicy: Use spicy horseradish to kick up the heat of your sauce.

Sugar-Free: The written recipe contains 20 grams in each cup of sauce. Replace the creamy horseradish and white sugar with sugar-free substitutes, to make it sugar-free.

Tips for the Best Copycat Arby’s Horsey Sauce

• I have heard of people mixing this horseradish sauce with a bit of sour cream and putting it on their baked potatoes.
• Horsey sauce works great with prime rib

What to Serve with Copycat Arby’s Horsey Sauce

With this recipe, you can experiment with all the different ways to use Arby’s Horsey Sauce in your meals, and at a fraction of the cost of dining out!

Here are some other copycat recipes you can serve to the entire family.

Sides: Texas Roadhouse Butter, Olive Garden Marinara Sauce, Cheddar Bay Biscuits, Olive Garden Chicken Gnocchi Soup, Olive Garden Pasta e fa*gioli, Chili's Queso, El Pollo Loco Avocado Salsa, Texas Roadhouse Loaded Sweet Potato, CrockPot Olive Garden MInestrone

Don't forget the French Fries and Onion Rings.

Main Dishes: Egg McMuffins, Cracker Barrel Pecan Pancakes, Cracker Barrel Pancakes, Cracker Barrel Broccoli Cheddar Chicken, Cracker Barrel Chicken and Dumplings, Carnival Cruise Guy's Burger Joint Pig Patty Burger, Wendy's Chili, KFC Famous Bowl

Desserts: Hostess Chocolate Cupcakes, Olive Garden Lemon Cream Cake, Carl's Jr. Pop Tart Ice Cream Sandwich, Homemade Twinkies, Carnival Cruise Chocolate Melting Cake

Drinks: Starbucks Frappuccino, Orange Julius, McDonald's Sweet Tea, Cherry Limeade Sonic Drink, Banana Julius, Arby's Jamocha Shake, Strawberry Julius, Sonic Peanut Butter Shake, Dunkin' Donuts Coolatta, Sonic Coconut Cream Pie Shake, Chick-fil-A Frosted Coffee

When to Serve

• Lunch
• Dinner
• Anytime you need a delicious sandwich condiment!

Great Copycat Sauce Recipes

Chick-fil-A Sauce

Red Robin Campfire Sauce

Olive Garden Alfredo Sauce

Olive Garden Marinara Sauce

Texas Roadhouse Butter

Chili’s Salsa

Big Mac Sauce

Raising Cane's Sauce

Do you love recipes? Check out our copycat recipes, dessert recipes, and our CrockPot Recipes.

Follow Tammilee Tips on MSN, Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest for all our recipe posts.